‘Scrubs’ Season 1 TV Review: Zach Braff Anchors Zippy Revival with Original Run’s Dramedy Balance [B]
Scrubs, the medical sitcom that aired on NBC from 2001 to 2008 before shifting to ABC through 2010, was once one of television’s most inventive dramedies. Its tonal alchemy blended rapid-fire one-liners and absurdist fantasy cutaways with devastating emotional turns and quiet interior moments from characters that often appeared unbreakable on the surface. At the time, it felt genuinely groundbreaking as well as a respite from heavy medical dramas like ER and Chicago Hope.
At the center was Dr. John Dorian, better known as J.D., portrayed by Zach Braff, a young doctor desperate to make a difference while still trying to earn the approval of his mentor. That mentor, Dr. Cox, played with trademark wit and buried wisdom by John C. McGinley, towered over Sacred Heart. His sarcasm was surgical, but the guidance beneath it shaped some of the series’ most powerful episodes, often anchored in quiet Cox–J.D. scenes where bravado gave way to hard-earned humanity and, at times, J.D. was the one steadying his mentor.
Orbiting J.D. were the colleagues who would define the alchemy of the series. Dr. Eliot Reid (Sarah Chalke) was a professional rival whose chemistry with J.D. led to an on-again, off-again romance. His best friend, Dr. Turk (Donald Faison), provided loyalty, levity, and the now-iconic “eagle” back rides that symbolized their improbable intimacy.
Carla (Judy Reyes), the grounded and seasoned nurse, helped many of these young doctors along, balancing the intensity of Dr. Cox and ultimately falling for Dr. Turk, resulting in what remains the healthiest relationship of the series. For this crew of characters, growth came slowly, sometimes painfully, and the audience was glad to be along for the ride.
Supporting presences on the series like Jordan (actress and music supervisor Christa Miller) added razor-sharp banter as Dr. Cox’s wife and foil. Neil Flynn’s nameless Janitor, whose long-running feud with J.D. evolved from poking at the young doctor’s insecurities into elaborate pranks and psychological warfare, became the stuff of legend.
In one of the show’s most clever meta moments, Scrubs folded in Flynn’s real-life role as a police officer in The Fugitive opposite Harrison Ford. The Janitor reprised the line “Freeze, Kimble!” not merely as a wink to the audience, but as a subtle acknowledgment that his history with J.D. was never purely adversarial. Beneath the pranks and psychological warfare, there was meat on the bone.
The show’s DNA and storytelling were equally intertwined with the music that pervaded the seasons. Needle drops like Keane’s “Everybody’s Changing,” “New Slang” by The Shins, John Cale’s rendition of “Hallelujah,” and Colin Hay’s “Overkill” became inseparable from the emotional arcs they accompanied. Scrubs introduced mainstream audiences to indie bands without making a spectacle of it; the songs simply arrived at the precise moment a character’s interior life matched the lyrical moment.
By its eighth season, however, the formula began to strain as the comedy grew broader. Character nuance became secondary to the jokes, and what should have been the end of the original run became a sitcom experiment as the series shifted networks. The ABC-attempted handoff aimed to hook audiences on a new generation of doctors, only the cast wasn’t written as compellingly, and the tonal drift became more pronounced.
With today’s revival, there is a noticeable recalibration. Braff has spoken openly about how the original run grew too broad in its later seasons, with joke attempts sometimes overtaking the grounded character moments that once defined the show. This new iteration feels consciously aware of that drift. The humor remains, but it is less frantic, more rooted in circumstance, and no longer trying to outpace its own sincerity.
The revival appreciates the strengths in its history and corrects one of the ABC era’s clearest missteps. Here, the new class of doctors is given distinct archetypes and complications, but they are not granted equal narrative weight to Braff, Faison, and Chalke. For any viewer familiar with the original series, it’s a wise decision to anchor the show around these characters. This trio formed the emotional backbone of the ensemble, and sidelining them previously diluted the chemistry that made Sacred Heart feel lived in rather than constructed.
Turk, in particular, feels like the most evolved presence on screen. Faison plays him with a grounded maturity that feels earned rather than imposed. The humor remains, but the writing allows Faison an incredibly emotional pilot moment and real grounding throughout the first four episodes.
It’s also clear that Reyes’ Carla takes a backseat to the collective screen time of the newcomers. That is not a criticism of the narrative real estate divisions, as these early episodes show Head of Surgery Dr. Turk navigating a life with far too many responsibilities to juggle. Carla is handled as part of the ecosystem shaping those pressures rather than driving a separate storyline of her own, for the moment.
Among the newcomers, Joel Kim Booster is sharp as Dr. Park, providing a smart counterweight to Braff’s introspective tendencies with added texture. Also punching into the fan-favorite column is SNL alum Vanessa Bayer. Bayer’s take on HR enforcer and wellness expert Sibby makes her a breath of fresh air with each appearance. Her delivery carries an understated sincerity that wrings added humor from the already snappy dialogue. There is precision in her timing, but also warmth, allowing the character to feel like a natural extension of Sacred Heart’s updated culture rather than a satirical insert.
Musically, the revival continues to understand its identity. Christa Miller once again uses curated needle drops as emotional punctuation. A particularly effective pilot needle drop leans into nostalgia, with the referenced band woven directly into the episode’s dialogue, while a new cover of a classic song provides genuine emotional heft at the close of episode four.
Under showrunner Aseem Batra, who worked on the original series, the emphasis shifts toward character-driven storytelling rather than late-run absurdism. Series creator and producer Bill Lawrence remains involved while juggling his three ongoing series at Apple TV+. It’s clear that significant trust has been placed in Batra’s vision for this first season.
With The Pitt already confronting the harsher realities of medicine in a post-COVID world, Scrubs wisely chooses not to compete on those terms. The revival avoids direct references to the pandemic, creating breathing room while still tackling modern medical realities such as TikTok doctor influencers, criminal patient billing, and difficult diagnoses handed out to seemingly good people. Scrubs has never been about stacking multiple procedural cases into a half-hour; it’s about how these characters navigate their work while wrestling with the complications of their own lives.
The revival does not attempt to reinvent the genre, and the restoration of balance is nearly there, though it still leans too heavily on jokes and sometimes oversimplifies its over-40 characters into predictable blind spots. When the revival leans into vulnerability rather than absurdist humor, it reminds you why the original mattered in the first place.
Grade: B
The Scrubs revival premieres February 25 on ABC, airing weekly on Wednesdays and streaming the next day on Hulu.
A voting member of the Writers Guild of America West (WGAW), the Critics Choice Association, and the Society of Composers & Lyricists, Burton began his professional creative career co-writing “Rest Young Child” with Oscar and BAFTA winner John Ottman for X-Men: Apocalypse. He has moderated Emmy and Oscar-season panels for major studios and guild nominees, and continues to contribute to Awards Focus, Awards Watch, and The Hollywood Reporter while developing his first original drama series.
On the Shelf: ‘Excalibur,’ ‘Westworld,’ ‘Network,’ ‘The Man Who Wasn’t There’ Highlight the 4K Physical Media releases for the Week of February 23 
‘Scrubs’ Season 1 TV Review: Zach Braff Anchors Zippy Revival with Original Run’s Dramedy Balance [B] 
AwardsWatch Podcast Ep. 334 – 79th BAFTA Film Awards Reaction 
79th BAFTA Film Awards: ‘One Battle After Another’ Takes Best Film, Director; ‘Sinners’ Makes History in an Evening Marred